Home Juicers Juicing Info How to Choose the Right Juicer – A Buying Guide

How to Choose the Right Juicer – A Buying Guide

Any links on this page that lead to products on Amazon are affiliate links and I earn a commission (at no extra cost to you) if you make a purchase. Thanks in advance for your support! Disclosure.

Juicers range from small, inexpensive appliances to large juicers costing hundreds of dollars. With so many options, it can be time-consuming to decide which juicer you should buy.

The best juicer is one that you will use, matches your juicing needs, and fits your budget. This is true whether you prepare juice daily or a couple of times a week.

What you will be juicing, time, noise level, budget, and the features you want in a juicer will help you choose the right juicer for your household.

Things to Consider Before Buying Your Juicer

What Will You Be Juicing? 

The types of fruits and vegetables you plan to juice are one factor in deciding which kind of juicer to purchase.

Centrifugal Juicers are suitable for firm-fleshed produce like apples or carrots.

Masticating Juicers are best if you want to juice leafy greens like spinach, kale, or wheatgrass. This type of juicer slowly crushes the plant leaves and extracts the liquids. Some masticating juicers make good citrus juice provided you peel the fruit first.

If you want to juice soft fruits like kiwi, peaches, or mangos, the soft flesh will often clog the filter on a centrifugal juicer and make them impossible to work with. A good masticating juicer is the best option for soft fruits. Learn more about one such juicer, the Omega J8006HDS.

Centrifugal: If you are only going to juice apples, carrots, etc.

Masticating: If you want to juice leafy greens and soft fruits more than once a week

Citrus: If you only want to juice grapefruits, oranges, lemons, and limes

Will You Be Drinking Your Juice Right Away?

For optimal nutrition, any juice you make should be consumed right away. However, if you have a slow juicer that requires a lot of prepping and chopping, you may want to save time by making juice ahead of time.

If you plan on drinking your juice right, any type of juicer will work for you. However, if you plan on storing your juice to drink over the next day or two, it's important to use a twin gear or masticating juicer.

The crushing mechanism of these juicers extracts liquid without using heat or introducing oxygen, both of which will impact your juicer's nutrition and shelf life.

In general, if you are using a centrifugal juicer, it is best to drink the juice right away and definitely within 24 hours. The juice must be stored in an air-tight container and refrigerated. Some people use mason jars; however, I use glass juicing containers.

If you use a masticating juicer, don't store the juice for longer than 48 hours.

Tip: I use lemons in my recipes and found that the flavors of the juice last longer.

Juices made with a twin gear unit can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 72 hours.

Centrifugal: Will drink juice right away or in less than 24 hours

Masticating: Want to store for up to 2 days

Twin gear: Want to keep for up to 3 days

Centrifugal juicer on a wooden table

How Much Time Do You Have for Preparation and Juicing? 

All juicers require produce to be cleaned and chopped and usually for seeds and rinds to be removed and discarded. However, some juicers have a larger feed tube that accommodates larger pieces of produce, while some have a small feed tube that requires the food to be chopped more finely.

Centrifugal juicers make juice very quickly but can be inefficient in extracting the most possible juice from every ingredient. Masticating and twin gear juicers operate more slowly but produce higher quantities of liquid. If you need fast juicing, you may want a centrifugal juicer.

Centrifugal: Want to prepare juice quickly

Masticating & Twin Gear: Willing to spend time juicing (preparing food for the juicer and waiting for the juice to be extracted)

Are You Concerned About Noise From the Juicer? 

In some households, it's essential to have a quiet juicer. Centrifugal juicers can be quite noisy, producing sounds roughly approximate to a blender, while masticating and twin gear juicers operate more quietly.

A quiet juicer may be a high priority for those who juice early in the morning, have sleeping children, or don't like the noise.

Centrifugal: Noise is not an issue

Masticating & Twin Gear: Do not want a noisy juicer

masticating juicer with fruit and carrots

How Much Money Are You Willing to Spend on a Juicer?

If you are determined to incorporate into your health regimen, you will be spending extra money. Pre-bottled juice from the grocery store is expensive. For example, a 16-ounce bottle of cold pressed green juice with tax can cost $6.00. 

The other option is to buy a juicer and the produce and prepare fresh juice at home. Produce cost varies according to where you live, the store you frequent, whether you buy organic or non-organic, the recipe, and how often you juice.

The following is a very rough calculation. Let's say you spend $16 a week on carrots, apples, celery, kale, cucumbers, lemons, and ginger and juice a 16-ounce portion four times a week (210 servings a year).

Initial cost of juicer $200

       Lifespan 5 years: $40/year

Ingredients: 16x52 = $832

Juicing at home: $832+ $40 (juicer cost)=$872

Cost per 16 oz serving $4.15 ($872/210)

Cost (estimate) of a high quality pre-bottled $1260 ($6 bottle x 210)

Buying pre-bottled juice: $1260

Juicing at home: $872

Savings per year: $388 (1260-872)

If the life of the juicer is five years, you will save roughly $1940 over five years.

One option is to buy an inexpensive centrifugal juicer and see how often you use it. You can upgrade to a better centrifugal juicer or a masticating juicer later.

Centrifugal: Least expensive

Masticating: More expensive than centrifugal juicers

Twin Gear: Most expensive

Which Type of Juicer Should I Buy?

The table below shows the features of the three main types of juicers. This article describes each kind of juicer in detail.

Feature

Centrifugal

Masticating

Twin Gear

Price

Least expensive

More expensive

Most expensive

Speed

Fast

Slow

Slow

Handles leafy greens well

No

Yes

Yes

Stays fresh

Best to drink right away

24-48 hrs

24-72 hrs

Food Waste

Most

Less food waste

Less food waste

Prep Time

Very little

More prep time

More prep time

Versatile 

Only used for juicing

Can be used to make foods such as sorbet, nut butters,  baby food, nut milk

Can be used to make foods such as sorbet, nut butters,  baby food, nut milk

Juicer Design and Features

Once you have an idea of what type of juicer is right for you, there are still a lot of overall design considerations that can separate high-quality juicers from lower-quality machines. You may want special features that make your life easier or use kitchen space more efficiently.

Here are some of the key design aspects you may want to consider.

Do you need adjustable speeds? 

Some juicers have adjustable speeds so that tough root vegetables can be juiced faster. 

Does it splash out your juice on the counter? 

Some juicers have spouts that are well-designed and produce juice in a gentle stream. Others tend to be a bit more erratic and can spurt or splash juice.

How much room do you have in your kitchen?

Some juicers can be big, heavy appliances that take up a lot of room in your kitchen.  

Cord length? 

Depending on the layout of your kitchen, cord length can be a consideration.

Do you need suction cups? 

Some juicers have suction cups on the base that provide extra stability and prevent accidental “walking.”

Filter clogging? 

Some juicers have filters that are more prone to clogging, which can reduce the efficiency of juice extraction or even require you to pause the machine and clean the filter during your juicing.

Do you want other features and a more versatile appliance? 

Some juicers also have other food processing attachments and capabilities, so they can slice and chop produce, make different kinds of nut butters, grind spices, and other kitchen prep functions. While it can be nice to have a more versatile device, especially if it takes up space in your kitchen, that can also mean a lot of attachments to store.

Centrifugal: Not versatile - only juices

Masticating & Twin Gear: It can process foods (nut milk, baby food, sorbet, etc.)

Final Thoughts

Hopefully, this buyer's guide has given you information on choosing the right juicer for your personal needs.

There are different types of juicers and a wide diversity of options, features, and choices within each type. If you are interested in centrifugal juicers, you can browse these reviews.

You can choose a juicer that fits your cooking preferences, available space and layout, schedule, and preferred juice type. If you are going to juice several glasses of juice daily, then the Tribest GS-P502B Greenstar Pro Juicer is worth reading about. You might decide it is a cost-effective investment.

Where to Next?